I’ll bet they’ve been recording these from inside the statue of liberty.

I have a few theories…1. A few weeks back Sean hit his head. He seems fine most of the time, but every once in a while he recounts a fictitious story of meeting Henry Winkler in an elevator. The gang plays along because…dun dun dunnn…one of them is the reason for Sean’s injury. They have made a pact not to ever discuss the events that happened that day and to play along with Sean’s repetitive ramblings as to not stir up suspicion.
2. Calculating the number of listeners has long been a thorn in the side of The Long Shot podcast going back to its inception. Despite tireless efforts of pleading with their public week after week to leave comments on their website and iTunes page, The Long Shooters could not settle on an accurate count. Finally, getting fed up with the previous estimate of being somewhere between 4 and 40,000, the gang began to concoct a master plan known only as ‘Operation Fonz.’ The Long Shootists now knew that “asking kindly” would get them nowhere with an apathetic, lazy American public. So The LoShoPo Crew knew they’d have to do things the hard way. Nothing illicits more of a response from Americans than annoying the hell out of them. Week after week Sean would tell the same story for his parting shot, culminating in 15 straight weeks of regurgitation. By the end of that marathon of monotony they’d have as good an estimate as ever for their demographics based on the number of hateful, outraged comments left on their various social media pages. The only question left to the LSP was “what would the story be about?” They’d sit in silence until each of them raised their head and gave a knowing look to each other. “An American treasure: Arthur Fonzarelli,” they all said in unison.
3. Or they just really REALLY like that story.